Vegan Protein Powder Roundup

Written by

“Where do you get your protein?” If you’re vegan, you’ve probably been asked this question more times than you can count. It’s really not a question as much as it is a veiled statement, “Vegans don’t get enough protein.” The question is asked, and the implication is made often enough, that even some vegans worry that they are not getting enough protein. The USDA daily recommended amount protein is 50 grams. If you’re vegan and you eat well, you probably get at least that much, so you can rest easy.

SmoothieHowever, once you start exercising regularly, your dietary requirements change. When you start exercising several times a week, your protein requirements can skyrocket from 50 grams a day to 150 grams a day, or more. It’s difficult to get a lot of protein without also getting a lot of fat or other stuff you may not want from regular old food, and that’s why protein supplements exist. Supplements can make it very easy to get a lot of protein without worrying about what else you’re getting in addition to protein. And of course, supplements can make it easy to get a lot of protein without having to micromanage your diet down the last gram.

There are a lot of vegan protein supplements, more than could be covered in a single review. Protein in vegan supplements can be sourced from soy, hemp, rice, peas, and more. What follows is a review of several protein supplements I’ve tried over the past couple of years while maintaining a cross-fit exercise routine. I’m reviewing them based on the criteria of taste, cost, amount of protein and anything else I feel like throwing in. I mixed all of them with water to drink them. All prices are manufacturer’s suggested retail price, but you are almost guaranteed to find a better price online. All supplements had about 120 calories per serving. I tended to avoid the soy based supplements for no good reason.

Life’s Basics Plant Protein – Vanilla Flavor
Protein Source: pea, hemp seed, rice and chia seed
Protein per serving: 22g
Price: $29, 15 servings per 18.6 container

I have a love/hate relationship with Life’s Basics Plant Protein. On the one hand, it’s actually pretty filling, which makes it great to drink in between meals. On the other hand, it tastes very odd. At this point I’d like to point out to none of the protein supplements I’ve tried really tasted what I would call “great”. At best, they have a flavor that one might call “non-offensive”. But Life’s Basics Protein had a weird combination of flavors that made me want to hold my nose and down it as quickly as possible. The mix of ingredients separated very quickly after it was mixed/shaken with water, which, in addition the odd taste, gave it an odd texture. In fairness, the problem of ingredients separating was common in many of the protein powders I tried.

Nitro Fusion Multi Source Protein – Vanilla
(Also sold as PlantFusion)
Protein Source: pea, artichoke, sprouted amaranth and quinoa
Protein per serving: 21g
Price: $43, 30 servings per 2lb container

For the money, this stuff wins. It’s relatively inexpensive, it tastes good and it has the type of packaging design you expect from a protein powder. You know what I’m talking about: big red and black letters in ALL CAPS yelling at you that this stuff has PROTEIN! It would fit in well on the shelf with the non-vegan protein powders at GNC. It mixes well and doesn’t separate (okay, maybe a little) and the taste is fairly mild. One caveat: when mixed in a shaker, it has a head that would put a badly poured pint of stout to shame. Lots of bubbles. I prefer this stuff stirred, not shaken. This protein powder is also sold under the name PlantFusion, with more subdued packaging.

Vega Sport Performance Protein – Berry Flavor
Protein Source: pea, SaviSeedTM, sprouted rice, hemp seed and alfalfa
Protein per serving: 26g
Price: $65, 22 servings per 28.9 ounce container

Let’s start with the price: that’s sixty-five dollars, American. That’s a lot. But this is Vega’s protein powder. Vega is the to go to brand for vegan athletes and makes a wide range of supplements. But still, sixty-five bucks. Vega Sport Performance protein is palatable and it mixes well enough (it does separate a little). I think Vega put a lot of work into making this stuff not taste terrible, and they largely succeeded… if your price range extends into the sixty-five dollar area.

MRM Veggie Protein
Protein Source: Grape Skin Extract, Blueberry Extract, Raspberry Powder, …
Protein per serving: 22g
Price: $30, 15 servings per 19 ounce container

The first thing I noticed after shaking this powder up with water was how thick it was. It’s the protein drink that eats like a meal. I haven’t made up my mind how I feel about that. On the one hand it’s filling and would work really well in between meals to curb any munchies I might have. On the other hand, I usually have to mix a lot of water with it to keep from feeling like I’m drinking oatmeal. Despite its viscosity, it tastes pretty good.

Garden of Life Raw Protein
Protein Source: Brown Rice, Amaranth Sprout, Quinoa Sprout…
Protein per serving: 17g
Price: $41, 28 servings per 22 ounce container

Unlike the other protein powders reviewed here, this one is raw. For a definition of what raw technically means, visit your local library. This protein powder also differs from the others in that it only has eighty calories per serving. Also, it does not taste good. At all. My method for tasting protein powders was simply to mix them with water, and this one really needed something more to cover the taste. It might be drinkable if mixed into a smoothie with bananas and blueberries (a couple dozen bananas might do the trick), but by itself I just found it unpalatable.

NutriBiotic Rice Protein
Protein Source: Brown Rice
Protein per serving: 12g
Price: $40, 90 servings per 3 pound container

In order to really compare this protein powder to the others, it’s best to double the serving size. Two tablespoons gives you 24g of protein with 120 calories. Even with doubling the serving size, this stuff was the least expensive powder I tried by far. However, like Garden of Life’s protein powder, NutroBiotic’s Rice Protein did not taste all that good to me when only mixed with water. It would likely mix well with rice milk or your vegan milk of choice, but drinking it with just water was not a pleasurable experience.

As I mentioned earlier, there are a lot of vegan protein powders on the market; those listed above are just a few. Feel free to add your own reviews in the comments!

Update: Check out Vegan Protein Powder Roundup Part II – 5 more vegan protein powders reviewed! 

18 comments

  1. Jeff

    Nice comparison Erick!

    I found a significantly cheaper option online though, through true nutrition.com (formerly True Protein). I found out about it on Robert Cheeke’s site. You can order custom mixes by the pound–I usually order 5 pounds of 65% rice protein powder, 35% pea protein powder, plus I add free stevia sweetener and natural fruit flavors.

    To compare to the NutriBiotic, three pounds of my custom mix from True Nutrition is just $16.25, plus shipping–under $25 total. It has the same protein content as NutriBiotic at15 servings of 24g per pound.

    • Jeff

      It tastes decent with the flavorings you can choose.

      I mostly use it in my patented plant strong raw oatmeal every morning. I put 1/2 cup oats, 1/4 cup of the protein powder, 1/3 cup of raisins, and a liberal dose of cinnamon in a bowl, then pour 1 cup unsweetened vanilla almond milk in and let it soak for 10-15 minutes. Tastes really good to me with the raisins and no added sugar.

  2. Rob

    Thanks Ericka and Jeff….I’m going to have to be on a liquid/no chew diet for a few weeks later this summer and this will help me figure out what to do to supplement my protein to help me heal.

  3. Shumila

    The first time I had Life’s Basics Protein (the sweetened version) I threw up. It was awful. It had this weird sickly sweet taste to it that I could not handle. They have a new unsweetened vanilla version that I can manage if I disguise it well enough. I have tried the others you listed at one point or another but never ordered the product again. My fave protein powder so far has been the Sun Warrior Raw Vegan. It doesn’t make my stomach feel strange like other powders have in the past. It is hypoalergenic and has a “98.2% digestion efficiency rating”, whatever that means. If you want you can email them at [email protected] and request some samples.

  4. Dana

    I recently bought Naturade Soy-Free Vegetable Protein powder. Have you tried this, or reviewed it? Could you give me any info you might have on it?
    Thank you!

  5. Pingback: Vegan Protein Powder Roundup | Red Hot Vegans
  6. Jax

    I’m looking for a protein powder that when mixed with water isn’t think like a shake. I have tried non vegan drinks like Isopure and am looking for anything with that consistency. Any suggestions?

  7. Nolan

    I have tried most of the ones on your list, but my favourite.. By a long shot, is called vegan proteins+ in vanilla or double chocolate flavour. Superior quality and mixes great imo

  8. Nolan

    Oh and by the way, I’ve had the vega proteins before and it gave me horrible bloating and gas. After doing some reasearch online it’s due to additional “filler” ingredients that are non-essential. I know they are marketed well but that doesn’t mean they care : )

  9. Christine

    Thanks for the great review! I tried the sample version of the vanilla Vega Sport Performance Protein and it’s awesome. I mix it with water, ice, a tablespoon of peanut butter, and a handful of greens and it’s delicious. It actually masks the greens bitter taste (using baby greens helps). Also, Sprouts sometimes has it on sale (the big container) for around $44. I just wait for that sale and then buy a few of them. Was thinking of trying some others, but it sounds like I hit the jackpot of the first try. Love your sense of humor and honesty in your writing:)

  10. April

    Ewwww, I hate Vega. It’s the worst protein powder ever. It has a strange metallic taste I can’t seem to get past no matter how I mix it. It obviously just me because so many people seem to love it. Ew, just ew.

    Thank you so much for the review, there are a couple between part I and II that I haven’t tried yet and hadn’t even heard of. I’ll be sure to get samples and taste away :)

  11. petsrfunny.com

    Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO?
    I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results.
    If you know of any please share. Many thanks!

    Here is my blog post Ethel (petsrfunny.com)

  12. Lorri

    Hello all, here every one is sharing such familiarity, so it’s
    good to read this weblog, and I used to pay a quick visit this blog daily.

  13. Flashing My 34 F Tits

    Admiring the time and energy you put into your site
    and in depth information you offer. It’s great to come across a blog every once in a
    while that isn’t the same unwanted rehashed material.
    Wonderful read! I’ve saved your site and I’m adding
    your RSS feeds to my Google account.

  14. Comments on: Nici - Bora Bora

    Hi exceptional website! Does running a blog like this take a lot of work?
    I’ve no understanding of programming but I was hoping to start
    my own blog soon. Anyway, if you have any suggestions or tips for new blog owners please share.
    I understand this is off subject but I just needed to ask.
    Thanks!

Post a comment

You may use the following HTML:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>